Will It Work? · Guide
MAC address filtering: what it blocks, and what it does not
By Bulan Sarkar, founder of ElectronicsInfoline (since 2000)
MAC address filtering, which some routers call access control, sounds like a lock on the network. It is closer to a guest list that checks name tags. This guide covers what the filter does on two router makers' models, what it cannot stop according to a phone maker's advice for routers, and why devices drop off the list. It is drawn from those three makers' support pages.
A MAC filter lets in or keeps out devices by the address they present. It does not secure the network: MAC addresses can be copied or changed, and the filter does not stop anyone reading traffic. Use WPA3 or WPA2 with a strong password for security, and keep a block list only for keeping one known device off.
What the filter does
One maker's routers block or allow devices, wired or wireless, from a list of blocked devices or a list of allowed ones (TP-Link). On a block list, the listed devices cannot use the local network or the internet; on an allow list, only the listed devices can (TP-Link). The other maker identifies each wired or Wi-Fi device by its MAC address (NETGEAR), and its older pages describe allowing a set list of wireless devices even when others know the Wi-Fi password (NETGEAR).
The details differ. On the second maker's current routers, “block all new devices” stops a new device from using the internet but still lets it on the local network, an allowed device needs both its Ethernet and its Wi-Fi MAC on the list, and the rule only applies to devices that join after you save it (NETGEAR). That maker recommends leaving “Allow all new devices to connect” selected (NETGEAR).
What it does not stop
A phone maker's recommended router settings say to set MAC address filtering to Disabled and not to rely on it to keep people off your network (Apple). It gives two reasons: the filter does not stop anyone monitoring or intercepting traffic, and MAC addresses can easily be copied, spoofed or changed (Apple). To secure the network, it says, use the right security setting instead (Apple); the WPA2 and WPA3 guide covers which one.
When a listed device stops matching
One phone maker's phones, tablets and laptops use a different MAC address for each Wi-Fi network by default (Apple). Set to Off, the device uses its hardware MAC; Fixed keeps one private address for the network; Rotating changes it (Apple). On an allow list, Rotating means the entry stops matching. The same thing breaks a DHCP reservation.
Range extenders cause the other common failure. On one maker's extenders, the devices behind the extender show on the main network under different MAC addresses, so the router blocks them; the fix is to add the addresses beginning 02:0F:B5 (NETGEAR). Another maker's extenders in proxy mode replace each device's MAC with a virtual one, and most of its extenders use proxy mode by default (TP-Link).
Set it up
On the first maker's routers, go to Advanced > Security > Access Control, turn it on and choose the block list or the allow list; a connected device can be ticked from the online list, and others added by MAC address (TP-Link). On the second maker's routers, go to ADVANCED > Security > Access Control and tick Turn on Access Control; with the box cleared, every device is allowed, even ones on the blocked list (NETGEAR). Before switching to an allow list, add the device you are using, or it may be cut off too.
Tips and tricks
- Copy each MAC from the router’s list of connected devices, not from the phone’s settings: the router’s list shows the address the router sees.
- Before you save an allow list, put your own computer or phone on it.
- If a phone keeps dropping off the list, check its private Wi-Fi address setting for your home network.
- With an extender, add the address the router shows for each device behind it.
- For visitors, a guest network with its own password is easier than adding every phone to a list.
What we would do
We would leave MAC filtering off and protect the network with WPA3, or WPA2/WPA3 if older devices need it, and a strong password. To keep one known device off, we would block it by MAC and change the Wi-Fi password if it still gets on. For a child's devices we would use parental controls, and visitors would go on the guest network.
Questions people ask
Does MAC address filtering make my Wi-Fi secure? No. MAC addresses can easily be copied, spoofed or changed, and the filter does nothing to stop someone watching or intercepting traffic. One phone maker recommends turning the feature off and using the router’s security setting (WPA3 or WPA2) instead.
What is the difference between a block list and an allow list? A block list keeps out the devices on it and lets everything else in. An allow list lets in only the devices on it; every new device, including a guest’s phone, is kept out until you add its MAC address.
Why did my phone get blocked after I added it to the allow list? Most likely its private Wi-Fi address. A phone set to a rotating private address changes the MAC the router sees, and the list entry stops matching. Add the address the router shows for the phone, and use a fixed private address or turn it off for your home network if you rely on the list.
Sources
Each figure on this page is quoted from the source below or worked out from them. Sources checked , each quote read again against the source in a second pass.
- Apple, Apple Support 102766: Recommended settings for Wi-Fi routers (MAC address filtering):
MAC address filtering, authentication, or access control Set to Disabled. … You shouldn't rely on this feature to prevent unauthorized access to your network … It doesn't prevent network observers from monitoring or intercepting traffic on the network. MAC addresses can easily be copied, spoofed (impersonated), or changed. … To secure access to your network, use the appropriate security setting instead.
support.apple.com/en-us/102766 - TP-Link, TP-Link FAQ 1067: access control (block list / allow list):
Access Control is used to block or allow specific client devices to access your network (via wired or wireless) based on a list of blocked devices (Blacklist) or a list of allowed devices (Whitelist). … In Blacklist mode , the controlled devices cannot access your local network, or cannot access internet either. … In Whitelist mode , only the controlled devices can access your local network and internet. … Go to Advanced -- Security -- Access Control
tp-link.com/us/support/faq/1067/ - NETGEAR, NETGEAR KB 24830: access control to allow or block devices:
The ACL identifies a WiFi or wired device by its MAC address. … Select ADVANCED > Security > Access Control . … When this check box is cleared, all devices are allowed to connect, even if a device is in the blocked list. … NETGEAR recommends that you leave this radio button selected. Block all new devices from connecting : With this setting, a new device cannot access your router’s or Orbi's Internet connection, but can still access your router’s or Orbi's local network. … you must enter its MAC address for an Ethernet connection and its MAC address for a WiFi connection in the allowed list. The access rule does not affect previously blocked or allowed devices.
kb.netgear.com/24830/ - NETGEAR, NETGEAR KB 23289: Access Control or MAC Filtering (wireless):
By default, NETGEAR wireless routers and access points will connect to any wireless device (computer, smartphone etc.) if the device user enters the correct wireless passphrase or key. By using the "Access Control" feature, it is possible to only allow a specified list of wireless devices to connect to the wireless network
kb.netgear.com/23289/ - NETGEAR, NETGEAR KB 25714: extender devices and MAC filtering on the router:
the MAC Addresses connected to the extender will be translated to different MAC addresses on the main network, therefore they will be blocked from getting internet access. … add all of the MAC Addresses beginning with 02:0F:B5 under the MAC Address Filtering or Access Control List section.
kb.netgear.com/25714/ - TP-Link, TP-Link FAQ 927: MAC filtering for devices on a range extender:
In Proxy Mode, Range Extender will replace each of its clients’ MAC address with a virtual MAC address generated automatically by Range Extender. … Most models of RE adopt Proxy mode by default and cannot be changed.
tp-link.com/us/support/faq/927/ - Apple, Apple Support 102509 (US): private Wi-Fi addresses:
By default, your device improves privacy by using a different MAC address for each Wi-Fi network. … Off: When set to Off, your device uses its hardware MAC address. Fixed: When set to Fixed, your device uses a private address, but the private address doesn’t rotate … a private address that rotates to a different private address every 2 weeks. … reset network settings on your device, it uses a different private address
support.apple.com/en-us/102509